
Our brains, as amazing as they are, sometimes don’t do us favors when it comes to how they “think” about our partner’s actions and words. Our default is to attribute negative intentions to them–or at the very least to view them with suspicion. This is because the brain prioritizes survival, moving us away from pain and hardship that it thinks is a threat. We survived by assuming that others were a threat before concluding we were safe around them. How funny it is that while trying to protect us, our brain can sometimes make our lives more difficult!
This is not the intention, of course, but rather the result of how we make sense of things that don’t make sense on the surface. This is why a well-lived life is an intentionally lived life. As we all know, some pleasurable activities are harmful, while some painful activities are good for us. We have to use our rational brain to convince ourselves to do hard things that are actually good for us, or avoid pleasurable things that can be bad for us.
This is usually not too difficult, unless the hard thing we are trying to convince ourselves to do is responding to an upset partner! When this happens, it is not very useful to “listen” to what the brain is telling you, especially if that message is one of the following:
- Run away/withdraw
- Attack back
- Defend yourself
- Shut down
So what should we do?
It can be useful to know how to “hack” the brain’s survival instincts at times. What this means is finding a way to trick ourselves into thinking differently about an action. An example of a brain hack could be when we put a toothpick in our mouths instead of a cigarette when we are trying to stop smoking. You hope your brain accepts the “oral substitute”, calming the craving for a cigarette.
THE QUESTION: With relationships, the most successful hacks are ones where couples shift their perspective on the problem and how they are thinking about it. The approach I offer in this article is one where you question the “truth” of what is going on. I like this hack because it is relatively simple, but very effective! It entails simply asking yourself, as needed: “Is it so?”
This question is a variation of any number of questions that work to put a wedge in our thinking. Our brains are very adept at writing a story about what is happening with our partner that may make sense to us, but have little to do with our partner. Taking a moment to ask yourself “Is it so?” is sometimes all the time necessary to stop the printing press of the mind, allowing us to become more curious about what might actually be bothering our loved one.
Here is an example. Imagine that your partner comes up to you and complains about you leaving your dirty dishes in the sink. As they complain to you, your mind might come up with a story like this: They are too sensitive about things. I cannot be myself in this relationship! I can’t do ANYTHING right! I will never be able to please them.
If you take a moment to ask yourself “Is it so?”, you are giving yourself a pause from the story in your head, which is enough time to become a bit more regulated. From this state, you have access to other information other than the story you need to survive. That information might look like one of the following:
- I forgot that they just cleaned the kitchen so it makes sense they would be upset about the dishes in the sink.
- I remember them telling me that their mother forced them to clean the house, but never showed appreciation for it.
- They told me they were stressed today and my actions did not show compassion.
- I did promise to do the dishes more consistently and gave them permission to remind me if I forgot.
Or even this one, though this may be more difficult to step into quickly:
- My partner is right–I should have cleaned my dishes right away–that is respectful towards our shared space. I am glad they called me out on this, holding me accountable to our relationship agreements.
IF IT IS IN FACT SO: But wait a minute, you might say. What if the negative story we make up in our heads is actually the truth? To be honest, this is rarely the case–but if you do reach that conclusion, I hope that you have first given it the “Is it so?” test. If the story in our head is in fact so, there may be a difficult conversation for us to have with our partner. If we choose to do that, we’ll at least be addressing something that needs to be addressed.
What might that conversation look like? Well, let’s say that it is in fact so that “you cannot do anything right in the relationship”–and your every move is criticized and judged because you are not doing it “correctly”. This might be a time to question whether the relationship is a good fit for you, but if you want to have a conversation with your partner before calling it quits, you could start by saying something like this:
“It is true that I left the dishes in the sink–I admit to that. But it feels like I can’t do anything right–is that how you feel about me in this relationship? It feels like I am constantly disappointing you, and that concerns me a great deal. I would like to understand how where you stand on this. Are you open to my efforts to do better?”
Not all discussions would look like this–it might be that you left the dishes in the sink just this one time, and that is a quick fix and easy to repair. So while you might be nervous to ask yourself “Is it so?”, it is always better to respond based on what is true than what we think is true.
*
Successful relationships are not models of perfect behavior, but rather models of mindful behavior. Successful couples think about the choices they have available to them, and the consequences of those choices, before choosing. This skill takes practice, but it is doable, and is easier to accomplish if all partners are intentional about it.
I generally suggest that a couple “team up” to make sure that false conclusions don’t become the truth of their relationship. This is making the problem something that is between you, not in one of you. You are teaming up against the problem, not each other, and you are doing this for the benefit of the relationship (which is composed of you two!).
With practice, you will be better equipped to notice the false assumptions coming into your head when conflict arises. Noticing these, taking a beat, and then choosing what is best for both of you in the moment is a strategy that will lead to greater understanding and connection. It is not necessarily easy to do, but it is easier than suffering with the false realities we make up about what is happening.
Just ask yourself, “Is it so?”









